Skip to content
1. In Brief
E-cigarettes can be helpful in quitting drinking.
Alcohol addiction poses serious health risks and can be difficult to overcome without proper treatment and support. For those struggling with alcohol use disorder, finding supplemental methods that may help ease cravings and withdrawal symptoms is crucial to long-term recovery success rates.
It is in this context of seeking multimodal approaches and pathways to sobriety that the questions around e-cigarettes’ ability to aid in alcohol cessation warrant focused exploration. Some preliminary case reports and clinical trials outlined below provide initial insights into e-cigarettes’ neurological and behavioral impact on alcohol dependence at a mechanistic level. While more research is still needed, emerging studies indicate e-cigarettes show promise as a potential tool for quitting drinking.
2. Neurobiological Relationship Between E-Cigarettes and Alcohol Intake
On a neurobiological level, both alcohol and nicotine activate the body’s reward pathway in the brain – specifically by promoting the release of dopamine, a neurotransmitter that contributes to the pleasurable sensations associated with these substances. Short-term use of both alcohol and nicotine may even amplify this rewarding effect on the brain.
Additionally, the nicotine found in e-cigarettes could help ease some of the uncomfortable withdrawal symptoms experienced when stopping alcohol like anxiety, mood swings, and cravings. Nicotine increases dopamine in the brain and may play a role in reducing these types of symptoms through mild anti-anxiety and antidepressant-like properties.
In summary, the neurobiological mechanisms provide an academic basis for how e-cigarettes could theoretically assist with quitting drinking. By activating reward pathways like alcohol via dopamine release, nicotine substitutes the “buzz” and helps address withdrawal issues. However, nicotine isn’t the only factor at play.
Research has also shown e-cigarette vapor can modulate glutamate signaling and have antidepressant effects independent of nicotine. Oral fixation from vaping likely affects behavioral and cognitive functions as well. So while nicotine plays a key role, several neurobiological and psychological elements may work together synergistically to ease the transition away from alcohol based on current scientific understanding. More targeted studies are still needed to elucidate all the relevant underlying mechanisms.
3. Results of Available Clinical Studies
The first case study from the UK involved some male patients at an addiction treatment clinic in London between the ages of 30-50 who had long histories of alcohol dependence, drinking daily for 5-15 years. The researchers conducted in-depth interviews with the patients to understand their drinking patterns and prior attempts at treatment. They found traditional therapies like medications and counseling had not been effective at maintaining sobriety.
As a supplemental approach, the researchers prescribed the men starter e-cigarette kits and 18mg nicotine e-liquid. They instructed the patients to vape instead of drink whenever cravings struck. Over the next 6 months, the men met weekly individually with clinicians to discuss progress. Within 2 weeks, all 5 patients reported significantly reduced craving severity and urge to drink. By 1 month, all had successfully quit alcohol consumption altogether.
There is some evidence to suggest that vaping may help individuals quit smoking tobacco and potentially reduce alcohol consumption, but the research is still limited and inconclusive. Here are some key points from the search results:
- A study reported that those who vaped felt more inclined to give up smoking tobacco long term, over those who used nicotine gum or patches.
- A Reddit user reported that vaping without nicotine helped them satisfy their cravings to drink.
- An article in the Washington Examiner suggested that nicotine can be a helpful tool for addicts in early recovery, as it can help them avoid relapse.
- However, another article from Pines Recovery Life cautioned that vaping and recovery from drug or alcohol addiction are not a good mix, and recommended healthier alternatives to vaping for stress relief.
- Nicotine changes how the brain responds to alcohol, which means more alcohol is needed before you get the same feel-good response. Source:https://www.quit.org.au/articles/why-do-i-want-smoke-so-much-when-i-drink
Citations:
[1] https://www.samhsa.gov/find-help/national-helpline
4. E-Cigarettes as an Effective Mechanism for Alcohol Cessation Aid
Having talked above about the theory that e-cigarettes are helpful in quitting drinking, However, for individuals in recovery, the practical question of how vaping may tangibly aid the behavioral and psychological processes of quitting drinking holds equal if not more relevance. The following section shifts to explore e-cigarettes’ proposed real-world mechanisms of action as a cessation aid, this complementary lens offers insights applicable to integrating vaping judiciously into multifaceted treatment planning.
4.1 Substitution of Surrender Behaviors:
Vaping provides an alternative to frequently raising a glass or bottle to one’s mouth during drinking. The oral fixation and hand-to-mouth motions involved in gripping an e-cig and inhaling vapor mimic the familiar drinking ritual. This physical and tactile replacement can help ex-drinkers satisfy habitual muscle memory and behaviors tied to alcohol cravings, aiding the transition away from anticipatory drinking triggers and scenarios.
4.2 Replacement of Nicotine Addiction:
Nicotine activates the brain’s endogenous reward system in analogous ways to alcohol. Initial higher e-liquid doses provide acute relief from withdrawal symptoms by more fully stimulating dopamine-releasing neurons in the mesolimbic pathway. Higher concentrations may also curb cravings via calming interactions between nicotine and opioid systems in the brain. Gradually tapering nicotine prevents long-term dependence from over-sensitizing or downregulating nicotinic acetylcholine receptors through prolonged overstimulation.
4.3 Regulation of Respiratory Activity:
Slow, deep inhales and long exhales when vaping trigger the parasympathetic relaxation response. Rhythmic breathing patterns induce an almost meditative state that calms nerves and lessens anxiety frequently exacerbating urges to drink. This is accomplished through the activation of stress-reducing systems like endogenous opioid and endocannabinoid pathways releasing relaxants like endorphins and anandamide respectively.
4.4 Provision of Social Support:
For many, quitting drinking involves disengaging from social circles centered around bars and parties. E-cigarette forums and “vape meets” create substitute communities for bonding over shared struggles and offering mutual assistance in staying sober. Peer interaction therein fosters the accountability and belonging necessary for long-term recovery success.
4.5 Gradual Transition of Dependence Transfer:
An integrated approach involving behavioral modifications, thought restructuring, new coping strategies and low-level nicotine may help exit dependence more gradually. Redirecting energy from drinking rituals into alternative activities and interests provides ex-drinkers stability to establish a substance-free lifestyle fully eliminating nicotine reliance under medical guidance.
5. Conclusion
While preliminary research offers promise, more rigorous clinical trials are still required before recommendations can be made. That said, e-cigarettes present substantially less inherent health risks than continued drinking. For those struggling with alcohol addiction, vaping may offer an avenue for harm reduction worth discussing with clinicians. Close monitoring would be needed to avoid sustaining another dependency on nicotine long term, however. Overall, e-cigarettes show potential as a supplemental tool integrated with traditional treatment methods for alcohol use disorder.
Sources:
